When Socrates met Wikipedia: the ultimate digital dialogue

When Socrates met Wikipedia: the ultimate digital dialogue

Written by Terry Lawson on December 5, 2025 at 9:29 AM

Gather round, fellow seekers of wisdom, as we embark on a whimsical sojourn across the vast plains of time and space, where our destination is none other than ancient Athens, and our guide for the journey is a curious contraption known to the modern age as Wikipedia.

Ah, Athens! The cradle of Western civilisation, where democracy was born, philosophy flourished, and togas were the height of fashion. And our protagonist? None other than the notorious gadfly of Athens, Socrates himself! What sort of digital dalliance might unfold should this ancient philosopher gain access to a colossal compendium of collective knowledge, updated at the speed of human error: Wikipedia?

Socrates' Quest for Truth, Now with Hyperlinks

Socrates, as history tells us, was not one to shy away from a dialectical duel. Known for his method of inquiry, Socratic questioning, he would prod and probe the minds of Athenian youth until their arguments collapsed like a delicately stacked house of papyrus scrolls.

But imagine now, dear reader, Socrates armed not with traditional scrolls, but with a sleek digital device of the future. Picture the curious philosopher seated at his favourite spot in the Athenian agora, peering down with furrowed brow at a glowing screen, scouring entry after entry on theoria and eudaimonia. "Aha!" he exclaims, "This is no mere shadow on the wall of a cave! This is a veritable Platonic feast of 1s and 0s!"

From Oracle of Delphi to Editor of Delphi

One might recall the story of the Oracle of Delphi, who famously proclaimed Socrates the wisest man in Athens. Well, blessed with Wikipedia, Socrates would now have the ultimate oracle at his fingertips. However, anyone familiar with the delightful labyrinth of citations and edit wars on Wikipedia might imagine the escapades Socrates would undertake in pursuit of untangling truth from opinion.

Despite the chaos, Socrates would likely revel in the endless citations, edits, and footnotes more than a symposium of straight-laced Dionysian devotees. He might even become the first verified user to question the veracity of citations not merely by footnote, but by foot. "I will not heed the claims of men with undue reverence," he would announce, "that is for the bibliophiles." Instead, he would engage in dialogue with the editors, challenging their assertions and pushing for greater clarity, his unique brand of crowdsourced peer-review.

From Hemlock to Homepage

In a bittersweet twist, one might ponder how the tale of Socrates ends when injected with modernity. Given his reputation for stirring the pot, it is all too easy to imagine our philosophical hero in yet another kerfuffle with Athens’ authorities, but this time, the stage is set online. Picture, if you will, a heated debate spilling from the agora into the worldwide web, with Socrates gaining notoriety as a contributor in the fervour of edit wars at the Wikipedia "talk" pages.

Instead of a final, tragic draught of hemlock, might we envision a "banishment" instead, a digital disengagement of sorts? "Off with his IP address!" declare the stewards of the site. Though cast into the realm of offline obscurity, Socrates, I assure you, would walk forward of his own volition into the world yet unplagued by pixels, cheerfully mulling over knowledge both ancient and newly-acquired, a proud progenitor of endless questioning.

Wisdom and the Wisdom of the Crowd

In the end, dear devotees, the intersection of Socratic method and crowd-sourced encyclopaedia presents a tantalising tableau where the sum total of human understanding is but a touch-screen away. Whether revelling in revelations or confronting the inevitable misinformation, Socrates would no doubt embrace this new intellectual playground with the curiosity of a child and the scrutiny of a sage.

Would Wikipedia's fast-paced, constantly-changing tapestry of tidbits alter the very nature of wisdom, or would Socrates’ methods hold fast like Athens' city walls? Only in an alternate reality, where the Socratic school converges with the digital era, could we eavesdrop on the discourse. Until then, we shall have to content ourselves with playful musings and the clickety-clack of our own keyboard-searching as we, like Socrates, inquire ever onward in our very own pursuit of knowledge.

Terry Lawson
Terry Lawson
Terry is a curious and imaginative writer with a passion for both history and technology. With a flair for humor, wit, and detailed storytelling, Terry paints vivid pictures of how historical figures and events might have unfolded differently if they had access to modern technology.